Hyderabad, We have a problem…

We’re running late again – apologies once more, but I’ve suddenly got rather more projects on the hob than I realised. Between the day job, the new novel project, editing the current novel project for publication this year, and the forthcoming SFSF Social event, I’ve had precious little time for what is more a hobby than anything else. (It’s also more than a bit off-putting to watch one BF Facebook fan-group, which seems intolerant of people with learning difficulties & autistic identities, slag off the members of another BF Facebook fan-group that doesn’t suffer from that intolerance.)

Anyhow, let’s leave all that aside for now and re-focus on the matter at hand: the grand climax of Flip’s arc with the Sixth Doctor. William Gallagher has written it – he put the poor girl through the wringer last time – what’s he going to do to her this time?

Big Finish Folly, Part 119 – Scavenger, by William Gallagher

ScavengerEarth, 2071. Orbital space is filled with junk – dead satellites, old booster rockets – and it threatens the space programme. The Indian Space Agency is taking the lead in removing that junk, using its new Salvage 2 rocket. Witnessing the events from a space station is photographer Jyoti Cutler – and a couple of uninvited guests and their big blue police box…

Flip isn’t too impressed to be looking down on the Earth from this great height. I suppose if you see one planet from orbit, you’ve kind of seen them all, but that’s a rather blasé way of looking at things. Surely Flip still has a sense of wonder about her? But it seems that at the moment she’s thinking more of home, of her family – time and peril have caught up with her at last. She doesn’t regret what she’s done, or where she’s been, but she’s tired and wants to go home.

And the Doctor is distracted too – for the last few plays there have been references galore to Peri and her uncertain fate post-Mindwarp. Flip can be forgiven for feeling that the Doctor’s attention isn’t entirely upon her. This isn’t a good combination. Mistakes will be made. Communication breakdowns. Whoops.

This is only the background arc of the story, however. The plot itself gets underway once the Salvage 2 rocket inadvertently wakes up an alien artefact that identifies itself as Scavenger. Scavenger has been dormant up here since the 17th century, when it integrated itself with an Indian princess named Anarkali, leaving her lover, Prince Salim, bereft – and, incidentally, immortal. Now Scavenger needs more parts so that it can continue its mission. And Salim has been waiting…

Trying not to be too spoilery is hard with this one. Gallagher wastes no time at all in putting Flip in mortal peril, sending her off on a spacewalk with no tether and no hope, with only a voracious alien satellite for company. The Doctor has to deal with Salim and his brash, imperialistic (and casually racist) English counterpart Jessica Allaway as he attempts first to save Flip and second to deter Scavenger from causing more chaos. There’s no real success in either objective – Scavenger fries a huge chunk of New Dehli, while Flip… well, let’s just say that there’s a reason her spacesuit is called a Baumgartner.

The character of Jessica Allaway – ex-Wimbledon champion, now overbearing representative for the ISA’s English sponsors and conniving to spoil the Salvage 2 mission – seems to unbalance the script somewhat. Not that she’s badly played by Kate McEwen (far from it), but next to the lost and doomed romance of Salim and Anarkali, and the Sixey/Flip dynamic, and the enthusiastic witness Jyoti Cutler (Anjli Mohindra), the character and her motivations just come across as a touch one-dimensional. The play doesn’t have a real villain as such – in some respects I’d contend that it doesn’t need one – and Allaway appears to have been put in there to tick that particular box.

The rest of the plot is a clever blend of Who-style space opera (the Scavenger device, Anarkali, the resolution of that thread) and present near-space technology (they mention whippleshields! And I got the reference!). And Flip’s obligatory cliffhanger is the ultimate descent….

So is this it? Will there be any more Flip adventures? Can Big Finish possibly get away with leaving a companion like this? Is it a fate worse than death? And – what about Peri?

All will be revealed next time, as we enter “Season Eleven” of the Sixth Doctor stories…

But meanwhile, to sum up Scavenger: it’s wonderful too see Big Finish creating some well-imagined near-futures, especially ones which don’t have a default Western culture setting. India is a plausible big-hitter in space operations and William Gallagher’s script and plotting is both tight and fresh in this respect. More diverse settings for the Doctor, please!

Buy it here


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s